Hah, this is super late but I've been listening to them for a couple of years. Saw them live in 2009 - good live band. I'd have to rank "El Cielo" up there at the top, an album based around the concept of sleep paralysis and Dali painting really piques my interest. "Pariah" was a very interesting concept to me, and every time I go back to it it holds up against the test of time. The "Stamp of Origin" segments could get a little annoying and sometimes break up the flow of the album, but "SOA - Horizon" is pretty kickass. The preachi-ness of that album got to me a little, as well. "Catch Without Arms" has some great stuff, but overall it kinda fails in coherency and is a little bit too much of a collection of singles for me. Great band, though. Really unique sound.